I just finished watching the last one (Episode 3) and it was in fact "dark" as it had been described. However, the first half was still filled with the lovey crap that makes me sick. I stopped enjoying the movies early on in Episode 6 because the Ewoks just seemed so pussy. Seriously, they were obviously structured like that to expand the Star Wars viewing audience. Actually I spent much of the last three movies just trying to put my finger on exactly what bothered me about them. I believe it has something to do with how they seem to be so commercial. Yeah yeah I know, everything is commercial. It just seems like there must have been a parade of consultants that were making the decisions about how to lay it out for maximizing financial returns. Things like
Q: What should the race on Endor look like?
A: We have market surveys that tell us younger audiences were bored to tears by the first 2 movies. We should put in a race that appeals to the younger viewers. This will get young viewers to hassle the shit out of their parents forcing both the children and the parents to watch. This will add significant return on investment. Here we have (drops stack of paper on desk) someone else's research that shows "teddy bears" to be popular with the young folks.
Q: How should Vader be deformed?
A: In order to maintain sales of the first three movies we have devised a DVD release schedule that will coincide with Christmas (because Jesus loves space movies) and will include a DVD pack of all 6 movies. We feel that Anikan's transformation to Vader must be justified and dramatic enough to keep people interested in watching the original crap. Therefore we suggest that he kill children and be burned. It ties up many loose ends nicely and provides viewers with a reason to hate him.
Q: Should we really include the annoying love scenes between Anakin and Padmé?
A: Our studies have shown that the ladies do not like to sit and watch fight scenes and big spaceships for two hours at a time. It is suggested that these love scenes be not only left in but extended to as long as possible to keep the attention of our female viewers.
All I am getting at, is that everything seems to be just way too perfect. Enemies attack one at a time, the guy with 4 light sabers can't figure out a way to use 2 to hold off his foe while using the other 2 to kill him, the crap between Anakin and Padmé discussing which of them loves the other more, people that only get injured because it gives them "character", the occasional brutal cliché to lighten the mood… bah!
I'll give it a couple of years and then I'll try again (starting at Episode 1 this time) and see what happens. frankly I would much rather watch Strange Brew, not because it is Canadian but because I think it is a monu"mental" task to parody Hamlet like that and have well over half the audience not even know that is what they are watching. Not to mention the better acting.